Oceangoing Cargo Ships Safety & Operational Matters
containerships operational matters
Oil Tanker Safety Guide
Home || Tanker Safety || Container Ship Handling || Commercial Management || EMS ||

Avoiding bunker fuel quantity and quality claims- Guideline for ship

Advertisement

The consequences of bunker shortage or off-specification bunkers can be very severe. A lower quality bunker supply can lead to ship engine failure, incur loss-time, and additional expenses for refueling. In many parts of the world, greedy bunker suppliers make tricks to supply less.

Both this situation not only increases the financial burden of a shipowner but also damages business reputation. Some critical considerations, therefore, need to be made for a safe bunkering operation.

A prudent chief engineer should keep a proper record of all bunkering events for future reference. To avoid fuel quality and quantity disputes, we have summarized below some guidelines that are standard for all cargo ship types.

The Bunker Delivery Note should be retained by the chief engineer on board three years after the bunkering. He should enter the bunkering time, type of FO, volume of FO, and sulfur content, in the engine logbook and the oil record book. Bunker fuel quantity and quality claims can be minimized if correct procedures are followed, as explained below.

First of all, it is crucial to segregate new bunkers from pre-existing fuel. Loading into empty tanks can resolve incompatibility problems, make measurements easier and reduce the chance of spills.Before delivery, the vessel's bunker tanks should be measured. Densities and correct petroleum tables should be used to convert observed volumes to volumes at standard temperature.

All findings should be recorded. A bunker loading plan comprising all tank measurements should be prepared before the delivery and expected tank contents on completion of taking bunkers. Always check that the bunker delivery note shows the type of fuel and quantity intended for delivery is as expected.

Bunker delivery note or sample labels should not be signed before the delivery. The barge should be attended to in the company of the barge master, who should measure and record the contents of all the cargo tanks, including any not designated for your delivery. The temperature of the fuel should be taken in all the tanks.

Signs of foam on the fuel surface or excessive bubbles on the sounding tape should be identified. It may indicate that air has been blown into the fuel. The chief engineer should check that the barge calibration tables have an official certification stamp. If not, a letter of protest should be issued. If the C/E is not convinced that the tables are correct, an independent surveyor should be called immediately.

bunkering guideline
Bunkering operation

If bunkering in the U.S.A., the record of the onboard meeting/training, testing of equipment and Pre-transfer Conference shall be entered in the deck logbook as follows: The Chief Engineer should keep the following documents on board for one year as the record of the practice of bunkering work:
  1. A copy of the telex (or facsimile) of the bunkering notice from the Fuel Section (or agent).
  2. The Bunkering plan prepared by the vessel.
  3. Tank sounding records taken during bunkering and data for refueling volume calculation (A memo used on the spot may be accepted as it is).
  4. The Check List for Bunkering operation which has been filled in.
  5. The list of personnel who have been engaged in the FO transferring operation.
  6. The Check List for open/closed condition of refueling-related valves has been filled in.
  7. The confirmation letters for oil leakage prevention (when refueled in Japan).
  8. The Declaration of Inspection (when refueled in the U.S.).
  9. Pre-transfer OSRO Notification (when refueled in California, U.S.)
  10. If confirmation letters of inspection for oil leakage prevention or similar documents are exchanged, the copy of such documents (when refueled in countries other than Japan and the U.S.).
  11. The bunker receipt duplicate.
  12. Chief Engineers reports on receiving FO or on other abnormalities and a copy of the Company instruction (if any).
  13. A copy of the protest letter to a bunker shortage (if any).
Fuel oil delivery: quantity

One method of adjusting the delivered quantity of fuel oil is by measuring twice. It is done by transferring the fuel from one tank to another by gravity. One of the first tank quantities measured is then dropped under gravity to an available slack tank, which will be measured last. Usually, this is achieved by transferring from a fuel tank aft to a slack tank forward, the gauging having been started in the aft tanks. Countermeasure - re-check the first tanks measured before delivery begins.

Ullage and soundings

The delivery barge contends that seals on sounding and ullage pipes cannot be broken. The deceit is usually backed by pretexts such as Customs seals or a seized sounding cock. Usually the only alternative to gauging the tanks is by measurement through a flowmeter.

Be wary of air being introduced through the meter to increase the measured delivery displayed. It is commonly called the "cappuccino effect" (see below). Countermeasures - do not agree to meter only fuel oil deliveries. If Customs seals are cited, issue a letter of protest, or comment on the bunker delivery receipt with counter-signature from barge master.

Flowmeter readings

Sometimes bunker barge flowmeters are fitted with a small bleed-off line after the flowmeter that returns the fuel being bunkered to the suction side of the barge bunker supply pump. It effectively means that the fuel is being passed through the flowmeter twice. The by-pass recirculation line may only be small in diameter but over the bunkering period, can have a big impact on the quantity of fuel bunkered.

Countermeasures- check for any suspicious lines after the barges flowmeter. Use the ship's flowmeter (if fitted) as a cross-check and question any significant differences. Ask to see the bunker barges flowmeter calibration certificate and check that the flowmeter seal is intact. Refer to the bunker barge cargo piping diagram to assist with the checking of any suspicious lines.

The cappuccino effect

Air is sometimes intentionally introduced by the supplier during the pumping of bunkers to the ship, which aerates the fuel being delivered. The common standard type flowmeter will not measure the quantity of fuel delivered but the volume of throughput. If the fuel has been aerated, this volume is made up of fuel and small air bubbles.

Thus the quantity of fuel being delivered is, on some occasions, considerably less than stated, because the flowmeter, which measures the volume going through it, reacts to both the bunker fuel and the low-density entrapped air and registers this as a large volume of oil. However, the mass of the entrapped air is so small that it does not contribute significantly to the mixture's total mass . When the bunker tanks are sounded, the soundings also appears correct as the entrapped air is still in suspension in the fuel.

When the air eventually settles out of the fuel oil, the level of the bunker tank drops. It indicates an apparent onboard fuel loss at the next sounding. Depending on the number of bunkers requested, the fuel shortage can be considerable and amount to a heavy financial loss, or result in a bunker claim. This practice is commonly referred to as the "cappuccino" effect.

Countermeasures- use a density meter to check the density. There are meters available that can measure the exact quantity of the fuel being delivered. Coriolis meters continuously provide online measurements of mass flow rate, volume flow rate, density, temperature, and batch totals- all from a single device. Coriolis meters have no moving parts or obstructions in contact with the fluid being measured and require little maintenance, flow conditioning, or straight pipe runs. Unlike volume measurement, mass measurement is independent of operating pressure and temperature, which obviates the need for error-prone density conversions.

For highly viscous fluids where entrained gas and air is unable to escape, direct mass flow measurement can perform better than volumetric meters and tank gauges. The Coriolis meter will give a more accurate measurement of the quantity of fuel oil delivered. These meters can be expensive and may require system piping modifications.

Combating the cappuccino effect for bunkers

Before loading bunkers from a barge, the following checks should be carried out besides to the ships bunkering procedure:
  1. board the bunker barge and verify, by sounding the barges fuel oil cargo tanks and using corresponding sounding tables, the quantity of fuel onboard the barge before bunkering commences
  2. if possible, obtain draft readings of the bunker barge before pumping begins
  3. check the sounding tape when sounding the fuel tanks on the barge and during bunkering for any evidence of air bubbles in the fuel
  4. ask to see the barges cargo pump used for fuel delivery and check for any suspect air connections. These may be quite small
  5. ask the crew how they intend to blow the lines after completion of bunkering and ask to inspect this arrangement before starting fuel transfer, to limit the opportunity to introduce air with the oil flowing
  6. check the barges flowmeter reading and confirm that the calibration certificate is for the the meter in question and is valid. Confirm that the meters calibration seal is intact
  7. check for suspicious flowmeter recirculation lines. These may be small but can have a big impact the quantity received onboard during bunkering, monitor every 30 minutes the quality of the fuel coming onboard by using the bunker sampling point. Check the fuel for any frothing which is indicative of air entrapment
  8. if frothing is suspected, board the barge and ask to see the line-blowing arrangement. If this has been used, it may still be connected, and the compressed air piping after the air isolation valve may be cold. It may be an indication that it has been recently opened After completion, board the bunker barge and verify, by sounding the barges fuel oil cargo tanks and checking the corresponding sounding tables, and calculating the quantity of fuel remaining on the barge. The difference from initial soundings to final soundings should give a good indication of the quantity of fuel off-loaded from the barge
  9. if possible, obtain a reading of the draft of the bunker barge after pumping is complete
  10. ask to see the barges draft tables and roughly calculate the difference in drafts from bunker start to bunker completion, and use the table to convert to tonnage. It will give a rough measure of the quantity of fuel discharged.

List and trim

Sometimes the barge may have a list or trim, and no correction tables are available. It is possible that in these circumstances, the trim or list is to the advantage of the supplier. Therefore, the purported amount of fuel onboard is more than that which exists. The difference between the apparent and actual fuel oil on board can be considerable, especially if the tanks have a large free surface area.

Countermeasures- If no trim correction tables are available for inspection before taking fuel oil delivery or gauging tanks, it may be prudent to make a written comment stating that "no trim correction tables were sighted". It should be countersigned by the bunker barge master.

Temperature

The temperature of the fuel oil is essential as it affects the volume delivered. If the declared temperature is lower than the actual temperature, less fuel oil is delivered. For the supplier, "gaining" a few degrees Centigrade means gaining a few tonnes. Countermeasures- check and record the temperature during the initial gauging and periodically until completion.

Calibration tables

It is not unknown for duplicate barge tables to be used. At first glance, these appear to be in order but modified to the advantage of the supplier. Inserted pages, photocopies, corrections, different print, and paper types are all indications of tampering. Countermeasures- check if the tables are original or a copy- issue a letter of protest when in doubt.

Water

If 1,000 tonnes of fuel is bunkered and it contains 1% water, it is effectively just 990 tonnes of fuel. A loss of 10 tonnes of fuel resulting from water content is a loss of approximately $7,0004

Water may be mixed with the fuel oil just before the bunkering takes place. "Sealed" samples are taken from the barge before the water is introduced and used as "official." Supplier samples. Another trick is not using water-detecting paste on the sounding tape. A water-detecting paste can be used for distillate fuel deliveries but does not work with black residual fuels as it cannot be seen as the color change. Sometimes an incorrect alternative paste is used, like chrome cleaner, which looks and smells the same, but does not change color on contact with water.

It is also possible that the supplier of fuel oil to the bunker barge has given the barge excess water. It can then be passed on to the customer who will be unaware of water being present. Bunker barges normally bunker fuel from the port oil terminals. The detection of excess water depends on the effectiveness of their procedures and checklists. Saltwater is sometimes delivered with fuels as a result of contamination by the bunker barge. There are many potential causes, including ballast water contamination, structural defects, and incorrect valve operation.

A common source of seawater ingress is ballast water entering the ship's bunker tank via a corroded sounding pipe. One of the main concerns over seawater contamination of fuel is that a chemical reaction between the sodium (salt) compounds in the water and the vanadium compounds in the fuel during combustion may cause high-temperature corrosion (hot end corrosion). The vanadium and sodium oxidize during combustion, which causes sticky low-melting-point salts adhered to exhaust valves valve seats and turbocharger turbine blades which in turn attract other combustion deposits leading to mechanical damage.

It should be noted that the ISO 8217:2010 standards state that the maximum allowable water content for all heavy fuel oils should be not greater than 0.5%. Excessive water represents a triple loss. Firstly, there is the loss of specific energy in the fuel, which will affect fuel consumption. Secondly, there is the cost of disposing of the water removed by the treatment system. Such water is unlikely to pass through a 15 PPM oily water separator, so it has to be retained for disposal later, with a cost to the ship operator. Thirdly, water will damage fuel injection equipment, cause corrosion and failure of exhaust valves and turbochargers.

Countermeasures- check using "Water in Oil" test. Issue a letter of protest if the percentage of water content is more than stated on the bunker delivery receipt.

There are other less sophisticated, underhand methods of reducing the real quantity of fuel oil delivered. These include "unofficial" piping between the storage tanks and other un-nominated tanks, such as cofferdams or void spaces.

Countermeasures- fundamentally, the care, diligence, and training of the staff responsible for fuel oil deliveries. The purchaser should obtain specification acceptance by the fuel supplier.

Summary

  1. fuel oil purchasers need to advise the ship's staff which grade of fuel they will receive and how it will be transferred
  2. fuels from different deliveries should be segregated as far as practicable
  3. all receiving fuel oil tanks need to be gauged and the results recorded before taking delivery of fuel
  4. do not sign any documentation until you have witnessed the event referred to in the document
  5. if the origin and method by which the supplier's sample was obtained is unknown then when signing for it, add the words "for receipt only- source unknown."
  6. fuel oil samples should be taken by continuous-drip method throughout the bunkering
  7. if the fuel oil delivered is supplied by more than one barge, a sample should be taken of each fuel oil from the supplying barges
  8. sign the bunker delivery receipt only for volume delivered. If the supplier insists on a signature for weight add "for volume only- weight to be determined after density testing of representative sample"



Related articles

What is low sulphur fuel oil and geographical areas where it is mandatory to burn such oil

Prior bunkering operation What necessary arrangements are to be made ?

How to keep a record of bunkering onboard ?

Procedure and guideline for ships prior bunkering operation?

Procedure and guideline for lub oil bunkering


Safety precautions prior transferring oil

How to report in case of an oil spillage onboard

How to use low sulphur fuel oil onboard

Bunkering safe procedure and detail guideline for ships



Safety checks prior discharging sludge from ship to reception facilities

Bulk liquid cargo handling - Ship to shore safety checklist

Ship-to-ship transfer / Operational guideline and check item for oil tankers

General precautions for tankers

Safety precautions prior transferring oil

Reporting oil spillage in foreign ports

How to use low sulphur fuel oil onboard

Operational guideline during bunkering

Fuel oil sulpher quantity frquently asked questions

What is fuel oil additive ?

Guideline for Proper heating of Fuel Oil storage tank

Dealing with low quality fuel oil

What is the procedure for fuel oil viscosity control ?

How to keep a sample of fuel oil received ?

How to keep bunkering record ?

Procedure for receiving lub oil

Precautions prior transferring fuel oil into storage tanks

Ships bunkering guideline- planning, preparation, safety checks & confirmation

Safety precautions prior transferring oil

Bunkering arrangement and safety factors onboard

Bunkering safe procedure and detail guideline for ships

What is fuel oil additive ?

Dealing with low quality fuel oil

How to keep a sample of fuel oil received ?

How to keep bunkering record ?

Acceptance / rejection of fuel in a quality dispute

Precautions prior transferring fuel oil into storage tanks

Requirement of towing arrangement in oil tankers, readyness, & training onboard

How to deal with ships power failure ? ....




Other info pages !

Ships Charterparties Related terms & guideline
Stevedores injury How to prevent injury onboard
Environmental issues How to prevent marine pollution
Cargo & Ballast Handling Safety Guideline
Reefer cargo handling Troubleshoot and countermeasures
DG cargo handling Procedures & Guidelines
Safety in engine room Standard procedures
Questions from user and feedback Read our knowledgebase






ShipsBusiness.com is merely an informational site about various aspects of ships operation,maintenance procedure, prevention of pollution and many safety guideline. The procedures explained here are only indicative, not exhaustive in nature and one must always be guided by practices of good seamanship.

User feedback is important to update our database. For any comment or suggestions please Contact us
Site Use and Privacy - Read our privacy policy and site use information.
Terms and conditions of use

Copyright © 2015 www.shipsbusiness.com All rights reserved.